ST. JOHN'S, N.L. 鈥� Two Indigenous groups in Newfoundland and Labrador are pushing back against the provincial government's recent decision to maintain the name of the historic Colonial Building in downtown St. John's.
The Nunatsiavut government, which represents Inuit in Labrador, and First Voice, an Indigenous coalition in St. John's, issued statements Monday expressing their disappointment.
"Premier Andrew Furey continues to promote reconciliation as something that is dear to him and his government," the Nunatsiavut government's statement said. "If that is indeed the case, then he should reconsider this decision."
First Voice said that while it supports public consultation and conversations with non-Indigenous people, decisions about reconciliation and decolonization "must prioritize Indigenous voices and those who have lived experience of colonization."
The Newfoundland and Labrador government announced Monday it would not rename the building, citing low support for a name change from respondents to an online survey. An accompanying report on the survey said a total of 215 people responded and 69 per cent of them said the name should remain. Just six per cent of all respondents 鈦爏elf-identified as Indigenous, the report said.
The pillared, limestone building stands at the top of Colonial Street in downtown St. John鈥檚, just beside a popular park. It first opened in 1850 to house Newfoundland鈥檚 colonial government, and it was home to the provincial legislature for the first 10 years after Newfoundland joined Canada in 1949.
The provincial Tourism Department discussed the need to rename the building 鈥渁s part of ongoing efforts in support of Indigenous reconciliation," in an information note dated Nov. 17, 2021, and first obtained by CBC News.
The department said Monday it plans to have the story of Indigenous governance told and represented at the building, which is under renovation to become a tourist attraction that will include tours and exhibits.聽
The Nunatsiavut government said it was consulted on the matter and that it had suggested the building be renamed "Parliament House." The word "colonial" has negative connotations, it said, particularly given the impact of colonization on Labrador's Inuit and on other Indigenous people in the province.
"Reconciliation is not comfortable," the Inuit government said. "By its very nature, it means having to make decisions that are not always popular, but necessary in order to ensure the interests of marginalized members of society are respected and protected."
In an emailed statement Tuesday, Grand Chief Etienne Rich of Labrador's Innu Nation said he was asked for input on the matter during one of Furey's regular meetings with the province's Indigenous leaders. The Innu Nation, however, was surprised by the announcement Monday that the discussion had closed, Rich said.
Though the name "Colonial Building" is a stark reminder of the province's history of colonization and the harm it caused Innu people, a name change would not erase that history, the statement said.
"Unlike the past, when Innu were an afterthought with no ability to impact the decisions of a colonial government, we can and will participate in the upcoming consultation process to ensure that Innu Nation鈥檚 history is accurately reflected within the context of the provincial narrative," Rich said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 16, 2022.
Sarah Smellie, The Canadian Press
